Let us be Human, by Sam Charles Norton

Sam Norton is a Church of England rector committed to teaching Christians about the big issues of our time. I came across his work through an essay on the theology of peak oil a few years ago, and wrote it up here on the blog. That essay has now become a book: Let us be Human, a call for ‘Christianity for a collapsing culture.’

The basic premise of the book is that the church needs to understand the converging crises of the 21st century and live out a distinctive response. The challenge to every generation of Christians is different. Ours is to shepherd our communities through the end of the oil era, and the inevitable collapse of the perpetual growth paradigm.

Norton begins by explaining peak oil, and then sets it as one facet of the larger problem of the growth imperative. “The predicament we face is that our way of life has been built up around the maintenance of exponential growth – and as that growth crashes into ecological limits, so too will that way of life.”

The middle section of the book looks at the root causes of this predicament. For Norton it is a crisis brought on by a lack of wisdom, and with a background in philosophy he is well placed to explore this idea. An over-emphasis on scientific rationalism has blinded us to other ways of thinking. We are capable of remarkable scientific and technological breakthroughs, but don’t know how to use them wisely. “Our sense of what is right, our sense of what is of value, our sense of what is human and what is humanly important – these things have all been ravaged by the dominant culture.”

Consequently, technology and science have become idols, in the Biblical sense of something that offers only false promises of life. Understood that way, societies that pursue consumerism and economic growth at the pursuit of all else are not just wasting their time, but undermining their own prosperity to satisfy the demands of their false gods. We may not literally sacrifice our children like the ancient worshippers of Moloch, but it’s our children who face the consequences of our decisions.  “The Western way of life, with its excess consumerism and mindless destruction of creation – this way of life destroys life” says Norton. “The vision of Christian life, of full humanity, is that there is a way of life shown to us by Christ which allows us to be all that God intends us to be.”

That vision includes greater equality, and a society that doesn’t leave people behind. It includes simple living and generosity. In means wisdom and forward planning. It also means saying no to the old order of things. “It is our Christian duty to turn aside from shoring up the existing Imperium and concentrate on constructing local communities which can sustain civility and the intellectual and moral life through the collapse of our culture.” As it happens, Christians have done that plenty of times before.

The book doesn’t explore this conclusion in any great detail, which is a bit of a shame. Transition Towns get a mention, but without elaborating. Norton writes that others have covered that ground and leaves it there, but those others haven’t spoken directly to the church, and a few starting points might be helpful. But this is a book about why, not how. Perhaps the practical advice is a separate project or another writer.

My only other complaint is that climate change only gets a passing mention. That’s because Norton is flagging up growth as the bigger issue, and climate change is technically a secondary concern. It can tend to crowd out other issues, so I can see why Norton downplays it, but knowing how easily many Christians overlook environmental issues, it would be a shame to give the impression that the climate doesn’t matter much. Perhaps it could have been mentioned alongside deforestation, biodiversity loss and debt as the wider symptoms of exponential growth.

If you move in mainstream Christian circles at all, you’ll know that Norton is swimming against the current here. In my experience at least, the church is no more aware of the growth dilemma than the general culture is. That’s a shame, because churches should be natural hubs for imagining an alternative lifestyle together – that’s pretty much what they’re for. Churches don’t build community, they are community. There’s a vital opportunity there if we can learn to see it, and Let us be Human deserves a bigger audience.

7 Comments on “Let us be Human, by Sam Charles Norton”

  1. Sam Norton (@Elizaphanian) May 2, 2012 at 3:13 pm #

    Thanks Jeremy. At one point there was more about climate change in it (and it could have been an alternate chapter one) but I’m happy that Peak Oil is actually the presenting issue right now. There are a few others in the church looking at how to take things forward – in particular Tim Gorringe is looking to set up a ‘transition church’ process, which I think will meet the need. An earlier version did have a more practical end (on my blog as ‘pledges’) but I wanted to focus on the spirituality, because it is that aspect which the church is most culpable in missing.

  2. dichasium May 3, 2012 at 12:36 pm #

    Of course most people want to know how they might survive the consequences of our human actions and if the church needs to live out a distinctive response we need to hear what that will be. But merely surviving life is (as it seems Sam Norton has said), missing the spiritual message that Jesus taught.
    The prime church role of relating Jesus’ message should be to show the link between the lifestyle we have been led into by the go-getting mentality and the lessons from Jesus. This is showing us how the blind lead the blind and to show this would be following Jesus’ example. I’m sure it is a separate ‘project’ from yours Jeremy. I have yet to read Sam Norton’s work and I hope that, if it’s not already done, he will make this link of the blind leading the blind, like lemmings off the cliff, absolutely clear to the widest possible audience as the church apparently, does not. I believe this is the most enlightening message. I hope those in a position to give it will think so too.

  3. Neil August 9, 2012 at 2:51 pm #

    Jeremy we are bring out a book exploring this issue in a few weeks time at Greenbelt “No oil in the lamp fuel, faith and the energy crisis” DLT. Our book we think is complementary to Sam’s, we talk about the transition movement and solutions. There is a lot less theology since we are not theologians!

    • Jeremy August 10, 2012 at 8:44 am #

      Great – good to hear there are more voices out on there on this topic. I’m not going to make it to Greenbelt myself this year, but I’ll pick up the book.

      • Neil August 10, 2012 at 2:08 pm #

        Thanks. Please tell everyone you know to buy it, I very much agreed with your final paragraph.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. What we learned this week | Make Wealth History - September 22, 2012

    […] understand and engage with the energy crisis. Last week I discovered a second book to put alongside Sam Norton’s. I’ll read and review No Oil in the Lamp, but until then here’s the […]

  2. No Oil in the Lamp, by Andy Mellen and Neil Hollow | Make Wealth History - November 1, 2012

    […] of two books addressing oil depletion from a Christian perspective. The first was Sam Norton’s Let us be Human, and now No Oil in the Lamp: Fuel, Faith and the Energy Crisis, by Andy Mellen and Neil […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: