Protest works – 37% of the time

Does protest work? That’s a question I’ve asked a few times, usually when opening an email inviting me to turn out in the rain to tramp past Westminster for some cause or other. My usual answer has been ‘no’ – you can get a million people in the streets for an obvious cause like stopping the Iraq war and it won’t make a blind bit of difference.

Big protests assume that governments can’t ignore a large enough group of people, which isn’t true. The government is quite capable of ignoring large groups of people and does so on a daily basis, whether they’re marching past their offices or not.

Then again, there’s no shortage of stories from around the world of people demanding change and getting it. Maybe it’s just a matter of circumstances, of seizing the opportune moment?

A recent paper from the Initiative for Policy Dialogue has studied the wave of global protests that have swept the world over the past few years – Occupy camps, food riots, Arab Spring protests, austerity marches, the whole shebang. They’ve noted the frequency, analysed who was protesting and at whom, what they wanted, and whether the protest succeeded.

Their conclusions are that “63% of the protests covered in the study achieved neither their intended demands nor their expressed grievances in the short-term.”

On average then, protestors are getting concessions 37% of the time. That actually sounds like a pretty good ratio to me, especially since many of the things people protest about can only be addressed over time, and incremental change is the only kind people are going to get.

Unsurprisingly, some demands are more likely to be met than others. Half of those 37% of wins relate to “political, legal and social rights, including the right to information and government transparency.” Economic achievements are trickier and of those, labour related demands are far more likely to succeed than protests about tax, pensions, subsidies, market reforms or austerity. Below that, “global issues and economic justice appear the most difficult areas to achieve change”.

So there you have it. Protest does work, sometimes, depending on what you’re asking for. Which is obvious really, and maybe I should be less negative about it.

Those interested in making change happen will find lots more to talk about in the rest of the research, which you can download here.

7 Comments on “Protest works – 37% of the time”

  1. Andy in Germany January 29, 2014 at 6:20 pm #

    One activist has suggested that although the protests against the war in Iraq were apparently unsuccesful, it may have slowed down governments considering further wars: would there have been an invasion of Syria or Iran by now if the governments had seen that the population was approving of it?

    I don’t know if this os corect (and as it is hard to prove a negative link, I never will) but it did make me think again about protesting.

  2. DevonChap January 29, 2014 at 6:25 pm #

    “Down with this sort of thing”
    “Careful Now”

  3. David Oldroyd January 29, 2014 at 6:59 pm #

    Thanks for yet another intriguing link that would normally escape notice (so far 336 downloads only), That “global issues and economic justice appear the most difficult areas to achieve change” is no surprise given the overwhelming dominance of the public media by ‘stealth deniers’ who largely serve the perceived interests of those with the greatest power and infuence. But we can indeed take some encouragment from the findings of this measured analysis despite the David and Goliath struggle for inter-generational justice,

  4. Theo Van Schopes February 12, 2014 at 5:21 pm #

    They may not work if you judge it on only one thing – i.e. did the protest against the new motorway stop the motorway being built. BUT they are effective in bringing issues to the attention of other people. This is a form of education, and education is important. Protests also have value because they bring people together, and if we really want the world to be a better place then we have to work together. After all, we’re all in this together whether we like it or not!
    So let’s keep on protesting!

    • Jeremy February 13, 2014 at 9:10 pm #

      That’s true, the power of protests to motivate people and show them that they are not alone is worthwhile in itself. But the survey did count concessions rather than outright wins – so small changes or the promise of change is included in that 37%.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. We Are Many – the biggest protest in history | Make Wealth History - May 22, 2015

    […] As we all know, the war went ahead regardless, but the protests were still hugely significant. It was the first globally organised demonstration, and for that alone, it has a unique place in social history. No protest had ever rallied that many people, bringing together all sorts of people who had never marched before. It set the stage for similar global movements in future, including the climate marches, Occupy and the Arab Spring – movements that do often get results. […]

  2. Why I’m joining the climate march on Sunday | Make Wealth History - November 26, 2015

    […] the biggest protest every assembled failed to stop the rush to war in Iraq. Even though I know that protest does work some of the time, I tend to think the government isn’t listening. There was a ‘march […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: