#dailyclimatedenial and the invisibility of climate change

In 2012 Laura Bates started the Everyday Sexism Project, a website where women could report incidences of sexism they had experienced in their everyday lives. It was a way of highlighting the issue at its most subtle, in our little interactions around the workplace and in public life. We know sexism, or racism too for that matter, at its extremes. We may not be so sensitive to it in its common garden varieties, and so it continues. By calling it out, in this case online, we can make sure that it doesn’t go unnoticed. It’s no longer okay, not something to be brushed off.

That’s something that Andrew Simms has learned from and is trying to apply to the world of climate change. Most of us are aware of climate change and might generally agree that we should do something about it. In practice, it never crosses our minds. It isn’t embedded in the media, or in our politics. In fact it is constantly undermined. The messages encouraging us to carry on driving, flying, and consuming as normal vastly outnumber the environmental messages we might encounter.

So Simms is calling out #DailyClimateDenial on a Twitter feed, and on the blog of the New Weather Institute. “Sometimes all it can take to break the spell is for someone to start pointing things out. So, the next time you see a patio heater outside a pub warming thin air and not much else, or other such acts of egregious daily climate denial, snap it, hashtag it, and share it.”

Part of me likes this idea. The silence around climate change is a huge part of the problem. We just don’t talk about it, and George Marshall has written very intelligently about why. Pointing out hypocrisy or blind spots could be helpful. I’m just not quite sure about the hashtag #DailyClimateDenial. It’s entirely true to the psychological definition of ‘denial’, where we live as if something isn’t happening. But we’re more used to using the word to mean refuting something, to say something isn’t true or didn’t happen – ‘we didn’t collude with the Russians’, that sort of thing. In a climate change context, denial has meant people who refuse to accept the science, and it may muddy the waters to start calling out hypocrisy or just inconsistency as denial.

For example, Simms calls #DailyClimateDenial on Elon Musk because he wants humans to visit Mars. Musk clearly gets climate change, and has invested a huge amount of time, money and effort into productive enterprises that are part of the solution. He’s also a billionaire sci-fi fan who dreams of inter-planetary travel. Those are not mutually exclusive interests. (I hope we get to travel to Mars too, eventually.)

So I’m not entirely comfortable with this particular campaign. However, Simms also says he was inspired by the ‘all male panels’ campaign, which picked on the specific issue of female under-representation on panel discussions. That was much more tongue in cheek, and made its serious point with disarming irony – often ‘congratulating’ organisers with a picture of David Hasslehoff giving a thumbs up. I suspect that a campaign highlighting the silence around climate change would be more successful if it had a bit more humour in it. Tone is important, and hashtags are more likely to be used and retweeted if there’s a sense of mischief about them, rather than just telling people off.

I can’t claim to have a better idea – maybe something about #ClimateSilence rather than denial? I’m not sure. If you can think of a better hashtag, let me know.

Tags: ,

3 Comments on “#dailyclimatedenial and the invisibility of climate change”

  1. DevonChap June 22, 2017 at 7:18 am #

    I’ve said before that wrapping those who disagree with the science of climate change as ‘denial’ is actually an attempt to quell freedom of speech and thought.

    Having the power to brand those who disagree with you as bad deniers is intoxicating and leads to expansion. First you brand those who don’t accept the science, then you brand those who disagree with its severity and then you brand those who disagree with the policies used to tackle it. At best we may end up following poor policies, at worst we have thought police.

    Deniers are portrayed as bad people whose voices should not be heard. Already several people have been basically banned from the BBC.

    It’s all very good when your side is doing the labeling but then you have to hope the other side don’t get the whip hand. And as any true liberal will say, “What if you are wrong”.

    This isn’t just climate change. Ask Tim Farron.

    • Jeremy Williams June 22, 2017 at 8:49 am #

      Denial is a strong word, and there is a time and place for strong words. I was reading recently about Miami and how it is experiencing flooding and encroachment from the sea, totally in line with climate change expectations. But when the mayor of Miami goes to the governor of Florida for support, the governor says that climate change is a hoax and isn’t happening. That’s denial, it’s dangerous, and it’s not wrong to call it what it is.

      But that’s different from creating an internet hashtag about it. Just as you say – it almost guarantees that its going to be misused. Like the example with Elon Musk. Or Michael Gove, who was being painted with the denial brush by the site recently. At that point it gets personal, it’s ‘othering’ people. It gets used for political means, and you risk undermining allies who just see things a little differently.

  2. jimella June 23, 2017 at 3:08 pm #

    I agree entirely with your main point. There is a very significant difference between denial and merely going on as normal, ignoring or overlooking the impact of everyday actions. A couple of alternative hashtags come to mind, although I don’t think either of them are particularly good (just an improvement on the one in use). “Ignoring climate change” or “Causing climate damage” seem possible, or of course variations/combinations of them, both of course with photos of the problem actions as now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: